Sam: It was no secret that Sam was a dog person and not a cat person; however, that didn't stop you from rescuing a small, orange tabby kitten on your way home from your supply run. Sam rolled his eyes when he first saw her, wanting as little to do with her a possible. Eventually, he warmed up to her and would snuggle with you and her on the couch. Sam would still complain about how he was pissed that it wasn't a dog you had rescued, though, you knew that he loved the cat nonetheless.
Dean: Boy, was Dean pissed. He was walking around the Bunker sneezing, wondering why. He walked into your shared room and saw you snuggled up and asleep with a white and fluffy kitten sitting in your lap. He walked out, extremely angry with you. As soon as you woke up, Dean was yelling. You yelled back, of course, and he stopped once you started. He didn't like the idea of a cat, especially since he was allergic. You begged and begged until he allowed it, but Dean said you could keep it, only if it never stepped foot into your guys' room. You were never following that rule.
Cas: He had always like the idea of a pet kitten, so when you brought one home, he was beyond excited. You couldn't contain your smile as you saw Cas playing with the tiny, black kitten who had striking blue eyes like he did. You joined them on the floor, rolling around a tiny ball with a bell in it to keep the cat occupied. He hugged you for what seemed like hours after he got over the shock of seeing a baby creature, thanking you and telling you how much he loves you.
Jack: Jack had noticed the kitten shivering in the cold rain on your way home from a supply run. Your heart clenched in your chest as you saw how sad it looked, so obviously, you had to take him home. Jack was sitting in the front seat with the cat in his lap, its small face buried into his shirt. He looked down and smiled at the brown cat, and you could tell that there was no way that he was letting go of it. Now, how were you going to explain this to Dean?

YOU ARE READING
Supernatural Imagines & Preferences ^Completed^
Fanfiction~REQUESTS CLOSED~ I love Supernatural. I love imagines and preferences. I thought I'd make one of my own 💘