Tyler Posey Imagines ♡

93) Misunderstood

Requested by ncbxbc 💕 sorry it's so late x

Tyler stood by the couch at his friends party, scanning the crowd. His eyes found a pretty girl, standing by her friends in the kitchen. She wasn't saying anything but nodding her head as her friend spoke. She didn't have a drink in her hand so Tyler thought it would be the perfect opportunity to go and speak to her.

Tyler always does this. As the school bad boy he has a reputation of hooking up with girls at parties and never speaking to them again. So every week there would be a new girl.

He made his way to the girl, smirking as he saw her friends tapping her arms. She looked up and met his brown eyes, as they bore into hers. He smiled at her as her friends left her alone.

"I'm Tyler", he said.

"Y/N", she said and smiled. He liked her smile.

"Are you a junior?", he asked as he didn't recognize her as a senior.

"Sophomore", she said and he nodded.

"Would you like to go somewhere more private?", he asked and she nodded timidly.

He grabbed her hand and led her upstairs to an empty room.

"How come I've never soon you before?", he asks her once they've entered the room. He takes a seat on the bed as she leans against the door.

"I don't come to parties often", she tells him and he nods, looking at her as she avoids eye contact.

He smirks slightly when she looks at him, catching his eyes on her. She looks down, blushing.

"Come here", he says huskily.

She looks up and stares into his brown eyes before walking over to him. He places his hands on her hips and she flinches at the unusual contact. He quirks an eyebrow at her.

"Everything okay?", he asks and she nods.

"Good", he says and pulls her closer to him so that her legs are in between his. His hands roam her waist and she shivers.

He moves further up the bed and tells her to follow. She's lying next to him now and staring up at him. He smiles slightly before leaning down and pressing his lips onto hers. She moans at the contact and he takes confidence in her reaction and continues, slowly slipping his tongue into her mouth.

His leg hitches around her waist to push her body closer to his and he moans at the contact. Her body feels incredible against his and he can't get enough. Slowly he starts taking off her top, and the more the clothes discard the more passionate they get.

Soon they are having sex. It was nothing more to Tyler but he did feel something different afterwards. She got up and got dressed, barely even looked at him. He swore he saw tears in her eyes but before he could ask, she was gone.

He tried to look for her or her friends during the night but couldn't see any of them.

***

The following week at school he tries to talk to her but she would always ignore him. On the Wednesday he looked for her at school. He spotted her standing by her locker, getting books out and putting them in her bag.

He walked up to her and leaned against the locker next to hers.

"Hi", he said. She looked up at him and her eyes widened. She looked back down and closed her bag before shutting her locker and turning around. He frowned before following her.

"Wait up!", he called after her but she just kept walking.

"Listen.. the other night.. I really had a good time and I was thinking.. we could do it again some time", he said to her. She stopped and looked at him.

"You really think I would do it again after how you treated me?", she said and he frowned.

"You didn't even ask me if it was okay that we did it.. even though I was and I knew what was going to happen.. but I just thought you would be more caring", she said which causes him to frown even more.

"Was.. was that your first time?", he asks and she looks down.

"Yeah it was", she whispers and his heart drops.

"I.. I'm so sorry", he says and she shakes her head.

"It was my choice.. I've always thought you were hot and I.. it was my choice. I was stupid to think you would treat me differently..", she said and he grabs her wrist before she can walk away. He leans down and attaches their lips together.

"I will treat you differently.. I haven't stopped thinking about you", he admits and she blushes.

"Let's talk about this later yeah? Meet me outside by the parking lot after school okay?", he asks and she nods.

***

After school she spots him walking out of the school. He rushes over to her and wraps his arms around you.

"I promise I'm going to make it all up to you okay? And the next time we.. have sex.. I'll be more caring okay?", he says and she blushes before smiling up at him and they go grab something to eat and getting to know each other.

x