4) He Stays The Night

8.1K 175 36
                                    

You and Tyler went to a friends birthday party. You two both had a few drinks so when a friend dropped you both off at your house, you didn't want Tyler going home so late.

"Stay the night", you whispered to him as he stands in between your legs. You were seated on the kitchen counter, drinking a glass of water with him mirroring your actions. He nodded while a slight flush crossed his cheeks.

You two had been dating for a few months now but he never stayed over because he was always working and didn't want to wake you so early in the morning. And because he didn't want you to be uncomfortable, so when you offered he knew that you were comfortable enough with him.

He helped you off the counter and you grabbed his hand before leading him towards your bedroom. You excused yourself to go change into your pj's. You were a bit self conscious about your body, and not entirely ready for him to see you change.

While in the bathroom, you were deciding whether or not to take off your make up. You hated wearing make up to bed but you didn't want Tyler to see you completely vulnerable. Your insecurities were staring at you as you looked at yourself in the mirror.

"Babe? You alright?", Tyler calls from outside the door.
"Oh yeah..", you say.
"Can I come in? I really need to piss" he says and you laugh before walking towards the door and opening it for him.

He eyes your Minnie mouse pj's and smiles.
"You look adorable", he tells you. You blush and look down.
"Do you sleep with your make up on?", he tilts his head. You shake yours and he raises his eyebrows.
"I.. Um.. I don't look nice without it on", you explain to him, not meeting his eyes.
"That's a lie", he says before walking over to the counter and eyeing your make up remover.
"How does this work?", he asks and you smile slightly at him before showing him where to pump the remover onto the cotton swob. He looks at you before pecking your lips and starts to remove your eye make up.
While he delicately removes the make up, your eyes fill with tears at how you think his reaction is going to be. You know he won't think you're pretty without it.
He stops his actions once he sees your tears and he pulls you close.
"What's wrong?", he asks cupping your cheeks.
"I-I'm not beautiful", you choke out, "I understand if you don't want to be with me", you frown.

He could have any girl but he chose you and you never understood why. Now that he's going to see you bare, you think he'll leave you because there's so many beautiful girls out there.

"I'm not with you just because you're beautiful. You're smart, funny, sarcastic, witty, kind and you're the best kisser", he says and connects your lips.
"And I think you're beautiful with and without make up", he says.

He continues to take off your make up and kisses your face all over once he's done.
"Beautiful", he whispers as he stares into your eyes. You wrap your arms around his neck and leave a loving kiss to his lips.

"Go pee", you say before he smiles. You leave him to do his thing. You climb into your bed, leaving your fairy lights on. He returns shortly afterwards and jumps onto your bed. You giggle as he wiggles his way towards you. He grins up at you and wraps an arm around your waist. You rest your head on his chest and listen to his heartbeat. He kisses your hair and you sigh contentedly before drifting off to sleep with the most perfect man next to you.

x
I need this in my life ^
Thanks for reading xx

Tyler Posey Imagines ♡ Where stories live. Discover now