Could it be you? (Bwwm)

Confrontation

Update: hey guys I've been super busy, but I'll try and write everyday and post whenever I can. Thanks for reading this!!

Jacobs POV
It's Monday morning and I already am at first period. Payton's not here yet but she should be soon. Meghan was at her seat catching glimpses of me when she could but all I was focused on was when Payton would walk in. I heard chatter from outside of the door and I saw Payton walk in with Cassie and Lexi through the door. She wore cuffed skinny jeans and a white v neck shirt and white vans. She sat at her usual spot and I went over to her desk. "Hi Jacob" she said While getting her notes out. I was kinda surprised she was talking to me first. "Hey Payton, how was Cali?" I asked. " it was awesome, I had so much fun" she said. "That's good! Are you still mad at me?" I asked cautiously. "No, I ought to stop holding grudges." She said. I sighed in relief. " okay then maybe we can have lunch today?"I asked. " sure" she said. "But Matt is coming ok?" " sounds like a deal." I said back. I went to my seat and class started. During class I texted Tiffany that the plan was to happen during lunch. She texted me saying that it was cool.
Payton's POV
I was ready for things to go back to normal with Jacob. hopefully this lunch thing wouldn't be too awkward. As the class got let out, I headed to my locker and transferred books and such for my next class. I felt some slight movement from behind my locker door and I shut it, and there stood Matthew. "Hi lovebug" I said cooing and crashing into his arms. I smiled super wide and he smiled back at me. "Hi princess" he said. He hugged me and then pulled away and planted a soft kiss on my lips. I kissed him back. "Did you have a good rest of the night last night?" He asked me. "Yea I did, I'm tired but it's whatever" I said. I grabbed his hand and interlocked our fingers while we leaned on the locker. " okay well for lunch I said I would have lunch with Jacob as long as you could come. Is that okay?" I asked concerned. I'm pretty sure that Matthew internally didn't Really like Jacob. "That's fine baby, whatever makes you happy. " he said smiling down at me. "Thank you Matthew, you are so kind. I love you bug" I said to him. "I love you too Payton." He said back smiling. "I'll see you in a bit" he said kissing my lips and slowly walking away. I smiled and waved goodbye. Only two more classes before lunch.
Jacobs POV
It was lunchtime, time to get the party rolling. I texted Tiffany to initiate the plan while I got Payton. I walked over to her locker and waited for her to finish putting her books up. She looked up at me and smiled. "You ready pay pay? " I asked playfully. "Yea I'm happy you want to do this. It means a lot" I said. I walked us into the cafeteria, where the school was selling chick fil a food. We took 4 steps into the cafeteria and I saw my plan in action. Payton gasped right behind me.
Payton's POV
My eyes brimmed to the top with tears yet I did not dare to let one drop. There I stood with Tiffany shelling sucking faces with Matthew in the middle of the cafeteria. She pulled him closer to her and kissed him way harder than she needed to. Her arms were wrapped around his neck and she ran her fingers through his hair. I'm done. I turned around and ran out of the cafeteria with Jacob not far behind me.
Matthews POV
What the actual FRICK. Tiffany just came up to me and started kissing me, I swear this is the dumbest thing. I pulled away sharply as she tried to deepen the kiss. "What the hell is wrong with you?" I shouted. "I really miss you and I don't think you should be going out with a junior. " arguing with her was the least of my problems right now. I just saw who I thought was Payton run out of the cafeteria and jacob following her. Her bag was left on the floor. "For the last time I don't like you Tiffany and I never will, leave me alone. I'd rather date all the underclassmen than date you." I spat. I picked up Payton's bag and ran down the hallway where I thought I saw her and Jacob go. Tiffany slowly followed me.
Payton's POV
I was sitting in the corner of the school in the isolated hallway sobbing my heart out. "I knew it was just too good to be true. My first boyfriend and he's a perfect senior? You're so stupid Payton" I said to myself crying. I hiccuped and jacob sat next to me rubbing my back. "Pay pay I'm so sorry, I told you to be careful" he said sadly. I wanted someone to comfort me but I didn't want an I told you so. "Are you trying to help me or make me feel bad? Sorry I'm a person who easily trusts people" I said while crying even more. Jacob put his arm around me and said" no that's not what I meant. I'll be right here for you Payton. " she leaned her head up and looked into my eyes. I really needed to kiss her. I leaned down and put my lips to here. Immediately she started squirming and she pushed me off.
Matthews POV
I was running down the hallways trying to find her but I heard crying and I turned the corner and saw her on the floor crying with Jacob putting his arm around her. I was heated. I silently marched over there and then he kissed her. She immediately pulled away and pushed him away from her. " Jacob what the FRICK!" She yelled. Oh hell no. "why are you kissing my girlfriend?!" I yelled. He stood up and looked me in the eye " because you kissed Tiffany" . I looked down at Payton who's eyes were red and face was wet with tears . I couldn't bear to look at her like that, it was painful. She made me happy and to see her depleted like that made me mad and even more upset. "Jacob Frickin Tucker, you know damn well I didn't kiss Tiffany. She came up and kissed me. And I'll prove it to you. You did this. I know you did." I said to him. "Well I kissed your girlfriend, also my best friend." He said back. I was two seconds away from punching his face. "You'd better leave" I said to him. I knelt down to Payton on the ground. "Payton, whatever you saw; was not the whole thing. It wasn't what you think it was." I started. "So it wasn't you and Tiffany kissing?" She asked irritatedly. I sighed. "It was, but in all honesty she is the one who kissed me. I didn't even kiss her back. I was in shock such a foreign pair of lips were even on mine. " I explained. "I'm gonna prove it to you that it was him, and he set me up to try and break us apart. Do you believe me?" I asked her.
Payton's POV
I believed him with all of my heart. I have a serious issue with trusting people easily like that, but he is the love of my life. He knelt on the ground and looked me in the eyes."maybe you were just too good to be true. It felt like a such a dream. At least I'm awake now" I said crying. "no Payton I'm not too good to be true, you're the one I should be saying that about. Please believe me Payton, I didn't kiss her. She kissed me. And I can prove it. " he pleaded. "I believe you Matthew. I'm taking a leap of faith and putting my trust in your side of the story." I said. He let out a s smile and pulled me in for a huge hug. He looked down at me and kissed my head. " I love you Payton and I wouldn't do anything to hurt you" he said. I hugged him back. "Hey he kissed Tiffany does that not mean anything?! " Jacob shouted. I completely ignored him "I believe you. You haven't given me a reason to not believe anything you say" I said to him. "as for you. I don't understand why you would kiss me, but thank you for comforting me " I said repectfully to Jacob . Matthew held his hands out for me to grab onto and pulled me off the ground and into another huge hug. I smiled and drew in his intoxicating smell. He looked down at me and our faces were resting super close to each other. His eyes were locked with mine. "I love you Payton, please don't ever think differently." He said against my lips. My stomach had butterflies and his masculine voice gave me chills along with his minty breath on my lips. "I love you too Matthew" I whispered back. He wrapped his arms around my waist and I hugged his neck. He leaned down for a kiss. His soft dream like lips landed on mine and for some reason I was so hungry for them. I kissed him back harder, with more lust. He usually lead the kiss but I took charge of this one. I bit his lower lip and he slightly opened his mouth giving me room to softly stick my tongue in his mouth. Our tongues slowly and softly swirled around each other. I then slowly pulled away and pecked his lips softly. That kiss made me hot.
Matthews POV
I'm so glad we made up, but I swear I'm gonna prove that it was Jacob who set me up. I kissed Payton once more after we ended that passionate kiss. I was getting hot and my buddy down south was getting excited so I had to stop. "Let's go back to class baby, and after I'll come over" I told her. "Okay" she said. I held her hand and escorted her back to class, because lunch just ended. I'm glad we made up.
Jacobs POV
If he finds out I set that up, I'll never be able to get Payton. Kissing her was magical. Her lips were so soft and plump and tasted like sugar. I wonder what she thought of my kiss. I'd better go try and get rid of my evidence of setting it up.