Pennywise x Reader Imagines

Teacher Part 4

3769 Words. Sorry for the wait! Please enjoy

*****

He stares at you, his eyes glowing golden. Your tears start to flow freely, he did kill her, didn't he? All hope for Jenny still being alive was slipping away. You needed to know! "Did you kill her?" You repeat with more of a sob when he doesn't say anything. You step back from him sensing a shift in the atmosphere. "Bill?" You step back. The wind began to blow you shudder at its coldness. "Bill, please talk to me! Tell me the truth!" You yell at him your mood shifted from sad to angry because of his lack of response along with the thought of him taking your best friend away from you. His teeth grew sharp and his hair turned orange. You watch him turn into Pennywise right in front of you but you didn't feel fear, no, you only felt anger towards him. "You hurt her didn't you, Pennywise?" Your protective friend instinct came out. You were not scared, only annoyed!
"Jenny smelt so tasty, very tasty, especially when she was screaming in fear." Pennywise smirks which fuels your fire.

"Bastard!" You couldn't stop the words from flowing out of your mouth as you storm up to him. He watches your every step curiously until he speaks.
"I could have eaten her all up." He licks his lips. You stop in your tracks, in front of the tall clown. "Tasty, tasty." He drools. His words push you over the line which made you slap him hard across the face. He stumbles back from the impact and looks at you in frozen shock. No one has slapped him like that before.
"You don't really care about me, do you? If-" your voice breaks you felt a few drops of rainfall from the sky. "If you did you wouldn't hurt my friend." Apart of your heart was aching for your dead friend and the other part was aching from feeling betrayed by Bill. He didn't say anything just stares at you in surprise holding his cheek. You couldn't take it anymore, you had to get out of there you felt as if you stayed there you would fall apart. "Fuck you, I've had enough of you and your bullshit!" You yell at him causing him to flinch from your outburst before you storm off. You couldn't breathe properly, your heartaches and your throat hurt from holding in a loud sob that was trying to escape.
"(Y/n), wait!" He calls in the distance with his normal 'Bill' voice and runs after you finally snapping out of his surprise daze. You didn't want to see him anymore after finding out what he did to your best friend. You break into a run. The rain starts to fall hard matching your emotions. You look behind you but the fairy lights had flickered out the whole area had a blackout as thunder boomed loudly in the distance and lighting flashed briefly lighting up your winding path. You follow a twisting path but soon come across the gazebo and stumble to it, deciding to wait out the sudden storm. You shiver violently as the wind blew hard through the gazebo. You watch the entrance and see, Bill, when a flash of lightning lights up your surroundings.
"G-get-t aw-way!" You shiver violently from the cold. "I-I don't want to see you after what you did." Your voice was shaking under the weight of your words.
"(Y/n), you never let me finish what I had to say!" He exclaims. "Just hear me out, let me finish what I have to say!" He steps into the gazebo. You didn't want to hear him out but you were stuck there anyway. You close your eyes for a moment to center your emotions again.
"Okay." You reply quietly after the few moments of silence.
"She was tasty looking and when I could smell her fear she was mouth-watering but then you-" he cut himself off and took a deep breath in. You stood up to leave. "but you crossed my mind as I was about to bite down on her flesh." You stop and look at his eyes glowing through the darkness at you. "I-I couldn't do that to you, I couldn't hurt you." He swallows "I don't want to ever see you hurt." More tears welled up in your eyes. "you saw her today didn't you?" He asks reminding you that you did in fact see her at school.
"Y-yes." You shiver. "B-but you can make people hallucinate, you could have done that to me."
"Yes, I can do that but that would be a lot of effort to pretend she was alive. What I really did was erase who I truly was from her memory. I didn't hurt her, I promise." He sighs "That's why she didn't know what you were talking about when you talked to her on the phone." He explains.
"Why the fuck didn't you tell me this from the beginning!" You exclaim at him feeling annoyed and still upset. You sit down, emotionally exhausted from the day's events.
"I couldn't bring myself to admit that you had gotten to me." He says sitting next to you. You move away slightly.
"You have really fucked with my feelings haven't you?" You glare slightly.
"I'm sorry, I was just confused with what I wanted." He looks down feeling ashamed of his actions. "I just don't ever have feelings for humans you know?" He closes his eyes and sighs before opening them again. "I have never felt this way about a human, ever! Will you please forgive me?" He begs. You turn and look into his eyes, you could see he meant it but you weren't ready to forgive him, he messed with you too much.
"I think I need some time to think." You shiver from the wind. His eyes held disappointment but he nodded.
"I understand." He then carefully places his warm hand on yours. "When you're ready to forgive me I'll be waiting." He says as he waves his hand over you and suddenly your clothes were warm and dry. You nod at him. "Are you ready to go home?" He asks standing up.
"Yes." You say quietly as you look down.
"Come on then I'll take you home, I'll owe you dessert for some other time." He holds out his hand offering to help you up.
"Okay." You say as the lights in the gazebo flicker on and you could see his beautiful perfect face. You hesitate but take his warm hand, feeling better about finally knowing the full truth. He pulls you up and then opens an umbrella (out of nowhere) and walks you to his car where he lets you into the passenger side. The car ride to your house was silent but once he pulled up to your house he spoke again.
"I really, really am sorry for everything, (y/n), I know I really fucked up and don't deserve it but I do really want you to accept my apology and somehow find it in yourself to forgive me." He touches your hand and you feel a warm sensation in your heart. "Now that I know that I want you." His eyes held that look that you still couldn't put your finger on.
"See you at school tomorrow." You say going to get out of the car.
"Don't forget your school bag." He says as he reaches for it. You look at his shirt buttons that look like they're about to burst open; part of you hoped that it would and show his smooth toned body hiding underneath but that was just your hormones talking. He pulled your bag into the front and passes it to you.
"Thanks." You avert your eyes feeling a little embarrassed about your thoughts. Hopefully, he didn't hear those thoughts.
"Goodnight, (y/n)." He says as you get out of the car.
"Goodnight." you leave the car and go inside. You sigh to yourself as you lock the door and quietly make your way up to your room. You get into your pj's and brush your teeth before collapsing on your bed. You lay looking up at the ceiling when you notice the balloon you got from Penny.