
#1
A 'Different' Kind of Love // Jeff...by 😈♠️Johanna🤪🏳️🌈
Y/n was an average high school student, he was the bullied introvert with no friends. His family kicked him out because he was gay. He was lonely. But little did he know...
Completed

#2
Dead Or Alive |Laughing Jack X Mas...by Matt
Slenderman has gone missing, the barrier to Slender Mansion has vanished, and all but two of the Creepypasta's, one being just a mere proxy, have escaped the grasps of f...

#3
Misunderstandings // A BEN Drowned...by ...
(Y/N) (L/N) was always a fan of creepypasta. She wasn't necessarily crazy obsessed with it, but she found the stories interesting. Sure she had pondered the idea of them...

#4
Silence | Jeff the Killer x Mute M...by Yanisleym
After your brother gets killed in front of you, you start getting taunted and manipulated by the man that killed your brother.
Completed
![To Live without Fear [Jeff the KillerxReader] by Jcreeps](https://img.wattpad.com/cover/36314463-512-k934566.jpg)
#5
To Live without Fear [Jeff the Kil...by Jcreeps
The one thing every living creature has in common is fear. Fear keeps us alive, drives us forward, and makes us still. Jeff the Killer thought he knew everything about f...

#6
Intrigued // An Eyeless Jack x Rea...by ...
what the title says
y/n uses she/her pronouns
if you prefer a y/n with they/them pronouns, I have another version of this story on my profile!

#7
CreepyPasta Scenariosby Blended Cucumber
Creepy-Pasta boyfriend preferences and Imagines
-Requests open-
Jeff the Killer
BEN drowned
Eyeless Jack
Laughing Jack
Masky
Hoodie
Homicidal Liu
Bloody Painter
Dr. Smil...

#9
My Imperfect (Various!Creepypastas...by ATwistedFate
This is a 'select your fate' kind of story. You will read through the common route, and then choose which guy you want to go after. I will be building up this story for...
Completed
![Vile Shade [Book 3] [Jeff the Killer x Reader] [JTK] by xXDarkQueenXxRei](https://img.wattpad.com/cover/44841029-512-k142516.jpg)
#10
Vile Shade [Book 3] [Jeff the Kill...by -≫ S 。N 。O 。W ≪-
THIRD BOOK IN THE KILLER ROMANCE SERIES (SPOILER IF YOU HAVE NOT READ THE OTHER BOOKS)
-+-
There were two years and six months taken from you.
Jeff described that time...

#11
Come Play With Me (Sally Williams...by Jace
Hannah Williams had a little sister. Her name was Sally. Sally died mysteriously after going to the park with her Uncle. Hannah always knew there was something off about...

#13
The Pains of Loving You (Jeff The...by namjin is my air
COMPLETED | BOOK 2 COMPLETE/
You grew up with Zalgo. He taught you everything you ever knew and helped build up your hatred of Slenderman. After you turned Sixteen Zalg...
Completed

#14
Jeff the Killer x readerby Kittypasta828
... im not to good with descriptions...
Check me out on Quotev! It is just Kittypasta.
Please enjoy. I update while I can.

#15
Sullen Son (A Jeff the Killer stor...by 🫀
Sequel to Heart Killer, read that first!!
-
After being separated from Jeff and moved across the country (Y/n) finds himself sick with regret and bitterness. Not only do...

#16
Fatalities (Yandere Jeff the Kille...by K
"...the string of killings with no apparent suspects still remains unsolved. Despite having a consistent method of killing, police have not been able to identify an...

#17
Intrigued // An Eyeless Jack x NB...by ...
what the title says
reader is nonbinary and uses they/them pronouns
This is a rewrite of my other EJ story which uses she/her pronouns
![The Scars of Loving You (Jeff The Killer X Reader) [BOOK 2] by yoongi_feverrr](https://img.wattpad.com/cover/71224024-512-k954246.jpg)
#18
The Scars of Loving You (Jeff The...by namjin is my air
COMPLETED! // [WARNING SPOILERS FOR 'THE PAINS OF LOVING YOU' BOOK ONE!]
"What..." I gasped, astonished.
"Hello traitor." He said.
"Bet you th...
Completed

#19
(DISCONTINUED)Creepypasta parent s...by Nova_Solanine
Scenarios of your favorite Creepypastas!!
Honestly I made this when I was 12, dont @ me my guy.
Story is {discontinued}
Requests are {Closed}

#20
Worthless - Jeff the killer x fem...by Francis C.
Kidnaped at 12 I'v lived at slender mansion for four years now. I work and maintain the grounds during the days while the creepypasta sleep.
Ingrained in my head over t...
Completed