
#1
Critical Role The Mighty Nein imag...by Heatha
There is not near enough reader inserts on Critical Role and I am thirsty, maybe I can help a little bit.
More writing and characters to come

#2
The Mighty Nein Incorrect Quotesby Gale Girlie ✨💜
Yep, another one, except for Campaign 2! Will have some spoilers, but I do try to keep it mostly spoiler-free.
Just about all of these I either get from Tumblr or Perch...

#3
The Winding Road by Donut
"So, ye want to hear a tale, eh? Well, I'll tell ye about The Fellowship, a group of unlikely heroes that come to view one another as family and eventually save the...

#4
Critical Role x Reader/Mighty Nein...by wayward_writings
several different oneshots and imagines about the M9 ☺️
taking requests for characters/prompts etc ☺️

#5
No Place Like Homeby Sunnydalesis
A Mighty Nein Fanfic. Based on Liam's Narrative Telephone "Widogast's Web of Words." Caleb tells the story of the Waldhaxe, but the other members of the Nein c...
Completed

#6
Critical Role Campaign 2 Oneshotsby Hibbleo
A collection of oneshots based with the Mighty Nein. Mostly fluff with a bit of angst mixed in. Ngl, this is mostly just what I would want out oneshots. Some ships and s...

#7
Critical Role Season 2by 8ellowing0rcs
Reader x Various or Character x Character, don't be afraid to send in recommendations!

#9
Over The Rainbowby Markimoobooboo
Idk I'm just writing because I feel like shit and this ship is a comfort ship. Haven't finished Critical Role yet, so no spoilers please! Also I Love Caleb, so if anybod...

#10
Hellish Bloodby pizzarollboi
So, I posted this on FanFiction.net with 4 chapters (it's still unfinished) and it hasn't gotten many reads. So I'm posting it here as well so that it might get better v...

#11
Adventure to Anemoreby wy
weewoo its shadowgast fanfic! they fight things and travel across mountains! (past and present tenses do change a lot) but I hope yall enjoy the vibes and the romance!!

#12
You Are My Sunshine, My Only Sunsh...by Kaylee Ann
Haylee was just your average college student. One day though everything was about to change.

#13
The Fey Demon of the Circusby Moved to AO3
{Critical Role}
What if they was another non humanoid creature in the midst of The Fletching and Moondrop Traveling Carnival of Curiosities? The fiendish 'Devil Toad' wa...
Completed

#14
Widogast Whispers - Caleb Widogast...by A person who writes
I was sick of never being able to find Critical Role Fanfiction I didn't like or that didn't go on long enough so I wrote my own. This is a Caleb Widogast x Reader fanfi...

#15
Against all odds by TM
The mighty nein continue their journey along the coast, finding treasure and secrets alike, until a fateful storm where Beauregard finds something worth more then the go...

#16
Drop Another Daffodil (Caleb x Cad...by foxtailfey
Fairy tales weren't Caleb's thing. They weren't meant for him. But what happens if Caleb has a brush with fate, in the form of the pink-haired flower shop owner from acr...

#17
Untraceable Footsteps ; A Critical...by OliverTheSilent
This is an au.
After finding Nott's husband, things did not go as planned. The goblin should've expected that she would get ridiculed and much worse by a man who hated g...

#18
You're A Book That's Not Yet Finis...by Sprinkle
You're A Book That's Not Yet Finished (But I Think I'll Stay and Watch You Fill the Page) - Reinaeiry
*****
A quiet moment between Fjord and Caleb.
Fjord pines.
Caleb...

#19
The lonely bard - Caleb Widogast x...by Fi / Teddy
Critical role spoiler free story line, separate from the main story line. I just love caleb okay
Story art cover from: @confusedswedee on Twitter!
Completed