Mylittleponycreepypasta Stories

Cheese Sandwich has come back to Ponyville to find Pinkie Pie punishing somepony for breaking a Pinkie Promise. Soonafter, the duo learns they have killing in common (wh...

Rainbow stumbles upon a cave in the everfree forest while trying to get away from a strange creature.

After the mysterious disappearance of the Mane Six, Scrub-a-Dub takes on the tedious task of clearing out Carousel Boutique. However, there are some places that not even...

I'm so afraid. I haven't been able to sleep for some time now. They keep me awake. Every night they come from out the shadows and speak to me. Every night I can hear the...

The fear Rarity is told to get over. The trauma that no one understands. The revenge that Rarity has never considered. She'll get over her fear. They'll understand he...

Tender Taps has grown tired of having his love be casually dismissed by Applebloom. She claims to only see him as a friend even with all their time dancing together over...