Every Witch Way

Something Doesn't Seem Right

Tony POV

Something didn't seem right about that Samara girl. I had to go back to the abyss. I had to figure out why.

There was no principal there, just Samara. I rescued Samara and left the principal behind. Did I.

"Tony, you've come back." The girl said, jumping up off the mattress she was sitting on (who loses a mattress. Come on people.) and ran towards me, wrapped her arms around my neck and hugged me.

"Something seemed off about the person I rescued."

"That was the principal. She used her powers to make us look like each other and you took her thinking it was me." Samara said. she also explained about herself. I think I'm falling for her.

"Well, we have to get out of here. Ready Samara."

"Ready."

I opened the door with my key. We sprung into the halls of Iridium high. We transported out of the school and into Daniel and Emma's house where the group was all there.

"Tony, you brought back the wrong person, and hello Samara. Samara!" Jax screamed.

"Something seemed off. So I went back and Samara explained everything. It was great." I said, blushing a little.

"Yeah. I even told Tony some personal things like what picture is inside my locket. Jax has been trying to figure it out for years."

"Hi, my name is Andi, Jax's fiancée. And he did not tell me that." Andi said very rudely to Samara.

"Hey Andi. I hope we can be great friends." Samara said.

Maddie POV

"Samara. I have a locket identical to the one around your neck." I said. Samara smiled and leaned in towards me.

"You want to see what's inside." Samara said.

"I'd love too." I replied. Samara opened the locket and I looked and I couldn't believe who's picture I saw.

"That's a picture of my dad." I scrambled to pull my locket out of my blouse and opened the heart. It was the same exact picture.

"Is there any way we could be sisters."

"Samara, if we were we would be half sisters."

"Come on. We need to find a mirror." Samara said, taking my hand and pulling me into the bathroom.

We definitely had the same blue eyes. Samara's hair was a little darker (dirty blond. I am a blond) and a little longer that mine.

Same cheekbones and the way our faces were set up. Almost the same height. Could we be sisters?

"Come on Maddie. You have to be at least thinking it."

"We can do a test. Pull a strand of your hair out."

We pulled a strand out of our hair each. I set it up and ran a test with magic to see if there was any DNA frequency matches. Match. Which means we have the same dad, just a different mom.

Samara POV

"I have an announcement. The picture inside my locket is a picture of my biological father. His name is George Van Pelt. Me and Maddie are half sisters." I said. Maddie went over to her husband.

I went over to Tony, who hugged me.

"Hey." I said to him.

"Hey Samara. Wow. You and Maddie are sisters. Good luck."

"Why." I asked.

"Maddie has a reputation of being a mean girl."

"I can deal with mean girls. My other half sister is one."

"Who." Tony asked.

"Her name is Mia. Its no big deal."

"Ah. So listen. I was hoping you were free Saturday night. And if you would, go out on a date with me."

"What's wrong with tonight Tony. You have powers. So do I. I could get ready in less time than it takes to snap."

"Okay."

"Hey guys. We were gonna go on a group date tonight, wanna come."

"Sure." Samara said and disappeared into the bathroom with Maddie, Andi, and Emma.

Comment on a hashtag for Tony and Samara's ship. Winner just gets their ship used in the story.