Castaway is a POS creator. He’s been problematic since the first time he ABANDONED Toby. He has stated that he wrote Toby (who’s a minor by canon) as a sex slave for Slenderman, and then in a podcast brought up the fact Toby (16-17 by canon) was in a relationship with Sally (who was canon at 8 in her story, but the was revamped to be 12 during the situation with Toby). He’s come back for Toby only now (because this is like the sixth time Kastoway abandoned Toby) because he’s a popular character. I encourage everyone to do what they want for him as majority of the CP fandom has decided Toby belongs to the Fandom now and Kastoway is not his creator.