Caulkinslord94

Hope you are safe and well. I want you to know that I am enthralled with your story. It has so many twists and turn I would never have expected. 
          
          What I truly appreciate is how you tackle the trauma these characters face and how they lean on one another for it. Each character faces their own struggles but the friendship anchors them along with the adults who care. Story wise, it’s a masterpiece. I am anxiously awaiting the continuation of the story through the next books. Thank you for this take on the Harry Potter universe. 

Polpotin

I hope you're doing ok OP. I've been binging your series for the past 2 weeks and it's been a delight so far. I am not a fan of the tsundere trope stories so your story is, as a far as I know, the only one out there that scratches the itch just the way that I want it to.
          
          I have to congratulate you on the way you recreated all the characters in this story, I specially love that you created Draco and Harry with arcs, personalities and flaws of their own, it shows that you created them for reasons other than their purposes (that is ending up being together, I hope)
          
          I love that Harry's troubled childhood gets treated with the seriousness that it deserves and he gets to work through that throughout the entire series. I love that Draco and her family get an arch of their own as they're trying to get out of old, corrupted aristocratic circles that have conditioned their family for generations.
          
          You take decisions that are not easy to write, like making the Malfoys likeable, and you make it work.
          
          I like that the dangers the trio go through are treated seriously and leave sequels on them as the story goes on. The second and the third book might be my favourite on this aspect. (1)

Polpotin

The way you described the diary and it's effects on Draco, how it takes advantages of the information she shares to eventually manipulate her into isolation from her support network, friends and family, how raw and brutal the climax is depicted as Tom Riddle takes over and attacks Harry. It actually terrified me. I don't know if you planned to do this as an allegory for grooming on purpose but it worked out phenomenally.
            
            And on top of that, you refused to let the danger dissipate and spent the third book dissecting the effects of the Chamber on the characters and the strain it caused on their relationship. You're a masterwork when it comes to turning crisis into growing opportunities for everyone involved. I loved it 
            
            Almost all of your changes have been a welcome treat for me, the way you handle relations to decisions that affect the main story, I never knew how much I wanted a story where Harry and Sirius get to live together as family, where Cedric lives, where the Malfoys and the Grangers rescue Harry from the barred window.
            
            If I have to dislike anything about this are the two inconsistency issues that I've seen so far, the displacement of the Weasleys and the love triangle in the 4th book. But I think I understand your narrative reasoning for the latter two, so I'm holding my breath on that one (currently on chapter 3 of book 5)
            
            I'm not someone who reads fan fiction and to be honest this was my first experience, and (so far) I'm glad it got to be this series I know I don't have a say on this, but please, finish this story, you deserve this recognition. If you need any kind of help with proofreading contact me on discord (user: kenny2202)
            
            Thank you. (2)
• Reply

Domesticated_raccons

Hey beefy! Your fic is amazing (much better than the originals). You did the side characters so much justice. Lucius's arc and character development is genuinely astonishing. Also, the way you write about the trios trauma is so vivid. 10/10 fic. Anyhow, are you alright? I noticed you consistently updated chapters from September onwards, and it just stops on Oct 13. 

Plunderyerbooty

If AO3 was up I'd know if beefy did that or not. I've honestly never payed thaaat much attention. Anytime they wanna fix their stuff! I'm like an addict that's getting really nervous about running out of their stuff lol
• Reply

Domesticated_raccons

@Domesticated_raccons one thing I will say though is I would really appreciate it if beefy was more transparent with their calendar and like updates regarding the progress of the fic. Sorta like how other fanfic authors use authors notes in ao3
• Reply

Plunderyerbooty

@Domesticated_raccons that could also be it. If that's what was going on (like a scheduled chapter by chapter upload) then maybe beefy feels like there isn't enough written yet to be worth a schedule. I'd personally prefer all at once as a reader since I download mine just so I can upload it to elevenreader lol. But if I was writing something worth reading like this I'd probably upload chapters on a schedule to possibly get more attention from 'regular updates' lol. So you might be right. Or it could be both or something entirely different like beefy is on vacation cause writing takes alot out of you lol.
• Reply