Select All
  • Sam Winchester x Reader
    68K 1.5K 6

    (Y/N) has a huge crush on Sam Winchester, and when he falls into the pit, you are heartbroken... only to have him come back soulless... So he constantly flirts with you and you have to keep telling him no.

  • Demon Girl (Sam Winchester x Reader)
    453K 14.1K 27

    A girl in love with Sam Winchester sells her soul to save his life. Later she returns as Crowley's Queen, and chaos reigns as Sam and Dean try to save her.

    Completed  
  • Sam x Reader: Stay Awhile
    124K 4.7K 18

    You live in a fairly large town, where the people that pass through are different everyday, and the people who pass through the diner you work in are even more varied. You meet a lot of different people in your town- especially hunters. So you began saving an extra room in your house for them. A place where they coul...

    Completed  
  • Don't Fear the Reaper
    394K 14.9K 75

    You are a reaper, actually one of Death's favorites. You've been following the story of the Winchesters for a while, staying out of sight, never letting them see you. You slowly fall in love with Sam, even though he doesn't know you exist. But that all changes one day.

  • Forgive And Forget? *Sam Winchester x reader Love Story*
    71.1K 1.9K 32

    supernatural love story which takes between after season 1 (y/n) - means your name just read it hope you like it!

    Completed  
  • His Eyes (Sam x Reader)
    20.2K 965 17

    So I wasn't so sure about posting this because it isn't finished, but I'd appreciate any advice and am in need of the encouragement to finish it because I get bored way too easily. So far, I have it set up to where the reader (you) and Sam will be a ship, Destiel will be a ship eventually, and Charlie is your best fr...