The Big Book of Anime One Shots and Lemons

Two Sides to the Story Eren x Reader Part 2

Same song inspired this part as well. It was a long chapter but it felt like it just dragged on.

She moves closer as..
He follows

"(F/n)" guilt falls in

He loves (f/n) but not like he loves Mikasa. If he did then he'd want to kill Levi as much as he wants to kill Jean for kissing Mikasa this morning, for being with her, being able to be so open about his feelings for her while Eren has to hide away, Mikasa only belonging to him for a short window of time, secretly of course.

"I'm -" Eren's eyes water

"Save it, we all know you love her, I'm not blind, I never stood a chance."

"That's not true."

"But it is Eren."

"It's not like you care, you've been sneaking off with him." Eren points a Levi

"You ignorant brat, she's known much longer, fuck she didn't even give me the time of day until she walked in on you two."

"Why didn't you leave me ?" Eren's eyes begin to water heavier as realization sat in

"I held out hope, Eren I was inlove with you, I was hopping it was a one time thing."

"It was." Eren pleas for her forgiveness, he knows he'll later need closure

"And look how it turned out,giving your 'one time thing' a necklace, you never even gave me a flower, a piece of weed growing from the earth Eren, but she gets jewelry."

"I've given you jewelry." Levi chirps in

Being ignored however.

"I'm sorry for hurting you." Truth is, he isn't sorry for hurting her, he's just sorry for getting caught

"And so am I, but Eren I don't love you anymore so it doesn't hurt and you never loved me as much as her so I'm sure you're no longer in pain either."

(F/n) runs off, she's hurt yes but she will survive, it's not like this was such a surprise.

"Tch, Damn brat didn't realize what he had." Levi shakes his head. "I knew from day one a diamond could never be with a piece of coal, diamonds are made to be cherished and what do you do, you throw her away like some piece of trash."

"SHE CHEATED JUST AS MUCH!" Eren yells as Mikasa holds him back

"Yes, yes she did, but how long has she known... A full year, Jeager."

Not even half as long as Mikasa's and Eren's secretly relationship started.

"Six months of that had been holding out hope for you., six months watching you both, laugh in her face, lie to her face." Levi stares with the same deadpanned expression

"I'm sure she's saved your ass a million and one times." Levi adds

"And I haven't ?" Mikasa questions

Eren came into the military with (f/n), she had witnessed his dark past, she understood every little problem he had, she once made him happy. Once.

However Eren never witnessed Mikasa get attention from another boy and when he did all of his interest left (f/n).

"I saw from day one, how you'd run off together leaving (f/n) behind, I told her, you know, that day was the first day I've ever been slapped by a fucking cadet." Levi looks back at the now weeping girl.

Yeah, it didn't hurt her alright.

"She had so much trust in you Jeager, now another man has to come along and clean up your mess."