MLP CreepyPasta Stories

Cupcakes

Cupcakes By Sergeant Sprinkles: World's Greatest Party Clown Edited by Edinpony WARNING: This fanfiction is incredibly gory, and may ruin your appreciation of a certain My Little Pony character as well as the titular baked goods. READ AT YOUR OWN RISK!

Diary Of Lucille

This book is the diary of the Creepypasta, Lulu. This diary will show you the dreadful life she's lived, but how that all eventually changes...

My Little Pony: Horror is Magic

Twilight finds herself in a mental asylum filled with blood thirsty ponies. When she tries to find her friends, she gets to watch them die at the hands of a silhouette. Can Twilight find the killer and save at least one of her friends?

The Shed (A MLP Creepypasta)

Fluttershy, the shy, kind pony we have all come to know. Well, what if that's just what she wants you to think, what if the shy pony that we gave come to know has some....dark secrets, one of them being she's a masked murderer under her caring personality. I don't own any mlp characters or themes, this story is NOT me...

MuFfINs- a MLP creepypasta

We know how rainbows are made in Equestria.... How Applejack grows her apples.... What makes Pinkie Pie's (or shall I say Pinkamena's?) cupcakes so good.... But how does Derpy make her muffins? The genre of this is horror FOR A REASON. Read at your own discretion.

"The Cough" [MLP CreepyPasta Fanfic]

Original story made by Ebon Mane. +A fan-made (sequel) chapter by me. ~ENJOY~

The Rainbow Factory- MLP Fanfic

Have you ever wondered how rainbows were made? Well, I'll tell you this, it's a very particular process.