Select All
  • never forget the times we had
    251 18 7

    Toby meets his long lost girlfriend and has to decide to kill her or and make her a creepypasta and leave her family and friends behind along with all the progress she made in school and fake her own death to live with Toby. But will she snap under pressure or forget about Toby ?

  • my killer knight in shining armour
    159 6 7

    chloe meets a killer and falls in love with the monster. she is abused and he swoops in and saves her from her parents and herself ..... which creepypasta is he?

  • love at first (attempted) kill!!
    287 6 5

    jeff's about to kill a girl but he can't! He finds his sensitive side ENJOY!

  • the demons in my head (jeff the killer love story)
    837 18 22

    jeff wasn't always the killer. this story is how I think jeff woods became jeff the killer. everyone thinks killers are mean and scary but the have a sensitive side. jeff meets the love of his life but they hit a few bumps in the road.

  • not normal
    193 12 6

    chloe is not a normal girl, neither is jeff.