Select All
  • I Can't Feel Pain, But I Can Feel Love (Ticci Toby X Reader)
    100K 2.7K 42

    13 chances 13 chances to kill her 13 chances to live. 13 Just 13 ???: "Time to Go To Sleep, little kitten..." Twelve to ten. Nine to seven. Six to four. Three to one. One... He's here to save the day, like a knight in shining armor. He won't let you die... Tick Tock... Tick Tock... *crack* ~~~ The Basics: YFN = Your F...

    Completed  
  • Lovely - Jeff the Killer x Reader
    454K 13.8K 29

    "Do I scare you, detective?" He asked in a dark voice. "A little." I admitted quietly. "Why's that?" He asked. I could feel his breath on my neck, making me shiver. "Because you could kill me." I whispered. "You're right, I could. But would I?" Jeff the Killer x Reader Foul language Violence Depiction of mental heal...

  • The Innocent Eyes (Jeff The Killer X Reader)
    500K 11.3K 69

    *100,888 words* Strange things happen under strange circumstances and sometimes the most unsafe people make you feel the most safe. When you meet Jeff, he's not exactly like the stories you've heard. Perhaps he's just broken, but aren't we all? Can you fix each other? Will he finally be able to love something, despite...

    Completed   Mature
  • Chains (Jeff The Killer X Reader)
    363K 13.3K 30

    Fate can be.. twisted. Sometimes to the point where it's too messed up to fix it. But what if.. what if it isn't so bad after all? "The more blood on my hands, the more my sanity slipped away..." ⚠️I DO NOT OWN THE ARTWORK FOR THIS STORY⚠️ ⚠️Slight profanity, bleeped out, though⚠️ ❗️I update throughout the entire week...

    Completed   Mature
  • SMILE (Jeff The Killer X Reader)
    123K 2.4K 22

    (Y/N) noticed a the new transfer student. Something weird about him especially his face. Nobody else in her class noticed it but she does.....later on she meet him at her house with the corps of her parents.

    Completed  
  • Carved Happiness ( Jeff the Killer x reader )
    400K 10.9K 43

    This is by no means a story of which a girl falls in love with this amazing, hot serial killer who is so protective of her in the slender mansion. This is twisted story. A story of gore and sociopathy details that gives the real meaning of Jeff the killer, a mad man who barely feels anything who somehow feels a slithe...

    Completed  
  • Marked (Jeff the Killer X Reader)
    286K 9K 15

    It all stared with a simple visit. A visit that was supposed to kill you. That night you were left with a strange mark on your chest, and that night your life changed. COVER BY: SlaveForGoogle NOTE: This story is years old so there's bound to be plot holes and sometimes just bad writing. If you can look past all that...

    Completed  
  • Stitched Kisses (Jeff X Reader)
    227K 5.2K 32

    "LET ME GO! " you screamed, it was no use. You were bound to this .. Machine and you couldn't move. Will someone save you?

    Completed  
  • You're a Sharp One (Jeff the Killer X Female! Killer! Reader)
    306K 7.3K 25

    "Now now.." Jeff's gruff voice whispered into your ear as he pinned you against the wall of your bedroom walls with his knife pressed against your neck. "You're always complaining how no one can catch you, but, you seem so frightened, with my knife against your [skin toned] neck. Face it. You're destined to death," he...

    Completed  
  • Forgotten Promises: A Ticci Toby X Reader
    322K 6.9K 14

    "You promised you won't leave me, that you'll always be by my side! Don't you remember?!" "No..." - Started: 071418 Ended: 061419 11.9K words Highest Rankings: #72 in shortstory (190k+ stories) #756 in fanfiction (850k+ stories) #65 in creepypasta (61k+ stories) #10 in ticcitoby (7k+ stories) #9 in ticcitobyxreader (2...

    Completed  
  • [ By The River ]
    58.1K 2.3K 8

    (ʙᴇɴ ᴅʀᴏᴡɴᴇᴅ x ʀᴇᴀᴅᴇʀ) . . . . . ''ʏᴇᴛ ᴛʜᴇ ᴡᴀʀᴍᴛʜ ᴏғ ᴛʜᴏsᴇ ᴍᴇᴍᴏʀɪᴇs ᴛᴜʀɴᴇᴅ ᴄᴏʟᴅ; |written 4yrs ago

    Completed  
  • Ben Drowned x Reader A Glitchy Heart
    228K 5K 35

    Y/n is a young girl who was beaten and mistreated at school. She stays with her step dad, who has disorders. His boss hates kids. So her step dad had the keep her in the basement with only her bed, desk, and lamp, but she finds old boxes and a old fashion computer. No windows, no sunlight, and no life. Y/n though eve...

    Completed  
  • Life changes (Completed)
    276K 7.3K 32

    (I changed my username and im too lazy to redo the cover again so thats why it shows a different one) Warning: this was my first ever fanfic I wrote on this account. I honestly hate it so much and think it's extremely cringe worthy but so many people seem to like it (Idek why) and that's why I haven't deleted it. May...

    Completed  
  • Tic Tock ( Ticci Toby x Reader)
    187K 5.2K 26

    What will happen when you meet Toby Rogers? You read that right! The Toby Rogers, better known as Ticci Toby, a very well known killer. Will you geek out? Will you get killed? Will you fall in love? Or will you hate him? Find out in this adventurous fanfiction! {I do NOT own any of the creepypastas, nor do I own...

    Completed  
  • Ben Drowned X Reader ~ Game On
    91.8K 1.8K 45

    Read at your own risk (I do not own any of the Creepypastas or pictures)

    Completed   Mature
  • Eyeless Jack X Reader
    2.8M 84.7K 64

    You manage to escape a facility where you had been experimented on. But will you be forever free? Will things go as smoothly as you hoped?

    Completed  
  • EJ X Reader
    136K 3.1K 22

    An eyeless killer on the loose. Y/N guessed it was just some stupid prank, but in the back of her mind she wants it to be real. Y/N's friends try to tell her that it's a creepypasta and that he was one of the guys who took a girl from their school. The missing girl was a shy, geeky, punk girl who hated the school anyw...

    Completed  
  • ERROR (Ben x reader)
    199K 6.2K 11

    Strange the lights keep going out every time your parents leave and the computer keeps showing Green codes? Not just any codes...they read..ERROR He's inside your computer... ******{UNDER EDITING}*****

    Completed  
  • A Game Worth Playing (BENdrowned x Reader)
    257K 6.9K 41

    Sorry if it sucks, its my first story... (I do NOT own any of the pics or creepypastas in this story)

    Completed  
  • Creepypasta Zodiacs ✔️
    10.2M 152K 202

    Oh look...another Creepypasta Zodiac Book... Sigh.

    Completed  
  • Ben Drowned x Reader
    501K 20.3K 38

    You're the main character in this story. As the story goes you start to fall in love with the newcomer in school as you start finding new and darker things around you. P.s. this book was written when I was 11, and currently revising the book. Also, check out our other books: Hoodie x Reader: https://www.wattpad.com/st...

    Completed   Mature
  • Creepypasta Zodiacs
    982K 9.7K 191

    There are so many of these, I know. I don't know if I will continue this, I started it because I'm REALLY bored. Hope you enjoy! BTW this is my first story and blah blah blah :p

    Completed  
  • Ben drowned x reader
    175K 4.7K 20

    "I-I shouldn't have done that . . ." "Damn right."

    Completed   Mature
  • Misunderstandings // A BEN Drowned x Reader Story
    818K 27.4K 52

    (Y/N) (L/N) was always a fan of creepypasta. She wasn't necessarily crazy obsessed with it, but she found the stories interesting. Sure she had pondered the idea of them actually existing but that just seemed crazy, like something that'd only happen in a book. However, one night she receives a visitor she was never ex...

  • Cry Baby - BEN Drowned x Reader
    330K 10.1K 28

    It started with tears, but will it end in tears? -BEN Drowned x Reader -Profanity -Mature themes -LGBTQ+ representation (cause fuck homophobes) -Don't be an asshole if you comment -If you don't like it, don't read it. Move along. STARTED: 09/22/19 ENDED: 11/05/19

    Completed  
  • ~Don't let me drown~ BEN Drowned x Reader [COMPLETED]
    217K 4.6K 12

    (Y/n) went swimming one day after a long day at school. She had always wondered what it was like to swim on a spring day without anything but her bathing suit and a few cigarettes. Anyways, as she swam along the lake, she kept seeing a green flash in the woods. Her heart pumped before being pulled down. As she strugg...

    Completed