In The Beginning

Team Free Will and the reader are transported into the French Mistake time (6x15). Dean has had a crush on the reader ever since they met 10 years ago on a salt and burn hunt. The reader also has a crush on Dean but they are both too stubborn and shy and bashful to admit they have a crush on each other. They are mysteriously transported to the real world because Gabriel was upset that Dean and the reader weren’t a couple. So, in the real world, they are married so they have to pretend to be the perfect married couple that they are.