New Priest in Town

Ella Marin grew up on the small island of Crocket. She recently moved back hoping to escape the troubles in her past, yet finds herself wound up in it again. Miraculous event begin to occur as the new charming priest arrives. Ella feels as though something is off about him, but she, and the rest of Crocket, haven't the faintest idea of what's to come.

Fanfic about Father Paul and the main character falling in love

MIDNIGHT MASS SPOILERS

Trigger warning: gore, violence, heavy religious discussion, alcohol, mention of eating disorder.

Characters and plot belong to Midnight Mass and Netflix.