Eleanor

Eleanor Shellstrop finds out the place she was sent to after she died was the bad place disguised as the good place. This results in the architect erasing their memory until he can get the Good place simulation perfect, so the participants never find out they are in the bad place being tortured. Each retry it fails , Eleanor eventually finding out. Each retry Eleanor, Chidi, Tahani, Jason, and Janet meet for the first time discovering their feelings for each other. This results in different people falling in love each time and different storylines. Let the drama commence.