•One//Warnings•

Colby wants to be with Sam, but Sam is with a girl and she's perfect.
Or
Colby wants to date Sam but Sam is dating Kat and she's absolutely perfect and so Colby wants to be like her so he can win Sam over

Bottom: Colby
Top: Sam

Disclaimer: This isn't how everything went, I skipped some parts in their past and not everything is accurate.